We help people with our preaching more effectively if we discern the implicit question being answered by the text we are preaching.
As preachers we often think in terms of giving answers. After all, we are the ones who need to study for hours in order to communicate God’s Word in a way that emphasizes its relevance to the people in front of us.
Here are a few quick thoughts, not about answers, but about questions.
In preaching terms, this would be the Subject-Question, that is, what is the passage about? We need to discern that question in order to then identify the answer being given, the Complement-Answer, that is, what is it saying about that?
We will always help people with our preaching more effectively if we discern the implicit question being answered by the text we are preaching.
Some may be technical theological questions stirred by hearing the Bible passage read. Most will be more mundane, but critical: why should I listen to you? Is this message relevant to my life? Is there any hope for someone like me?
We need to make sure we are not so soaked in academic thinking that we preach only answers to questions that most will not be asking.
Take the situation we find ourselves in today. Our culture has proactively shaped the question that dominates our thinking and therefore our lives.
Where the question maybe used to be, “how can I be happy?” or “what will satisfy me?” or whatever variation of self-concerned worldviews were dominant, now the question seems to be: “what must we do to stay safe?”
In just a few months our culture has made this question absolutely dominate the thoughts of the people in our church.
Identify what is driving the people you speak to each Sunday. Then question it. Overtly. In fact, let the Bible’s values offer a transformative interrogation of assumptions that nobody dares to question in our culture.
For example, how many biblical passages would support something different driving us in these days? Surely there is more to life than just trying to stay alive? Merely articulating that query could stir significant change in people.
I preached the final message in our Christmas series and we landed on Simeon and his “Now dismiss me…” prayer. His eyes had seen God’s incarnate, controversial, global salvation and he was ready to die.
In a time when all are overwhelmingly concerned about staying alive, it was very timely to ask a Simeon-shaped question: “are you ready to die?” and the other side of that same coin: “what does it mean to really live?”
We need to question the biblical text. We must question the values and thoughts of our listeners. We should be asking lots of questions about the paradigms and agenda driving our culture. We would do well to question our own assumptions, influences, etc.
And when we preach, let’s look to not only prepare using better questions ourselves, but also help our listeners to also ask better questions too.